Is Luxury Cruising Worth It? What Really Changes When You Move Up From Premium
By Marc & Judy
Short on time? Watch the video above for the full comparison, or keep reading for all the details.
If you cruise with premium lines like Celebrity, Princess, or Holland America, you may be curious what a luxury line like Oceania or Explora Journeys is really like, and whether it's worth the price.
Marc and I have sailed both sides. On the premium side, we've sailed Celebrity, Princess, and Holland America. On the luxury side, we've sailed Oceania and Explora Journeys. Here's what really changes when you make the move, what you give up, and how the costs compare.
What's the difference between premium and luxury?
The simplest way I can put it is this: premium gives you more to do, and luxury does more for you.
A premium ship is like a big, beautiful full-service resort, with lots of pools, restaurants, shows, and activities, and something for everyone. A luxury ship is more like a boutique hotel. There are fewer guests, the crew learns your name, and the whole experience is built around food, service, and the places you're visiting.
These are industry groupings, not official labels, which is why people debate where some lines belong. Oceania, for example, is technically considered ultra-premium, while Explora Journeys is luxury. Both are a big step up from the big ships, though, which is why I'm grouping them together here.
The differences show up in a few key places:
Size. The newest premium ships carry several thousand guests. Luxury ships carry from several hundred to about 1,250.
How you pay. Premium lines start with a lower fare, and you add what you want. Luxury lines cost more up front, but much more is included, so the price you see is closer to the price you pay.
Who's on board. Premium lines welcome everyone, including families. Luxury lines draw mostly couples and experienced travelers.
What's included
On a premium line, your fare covers your cabin, the main dining room, the buffet, some included venues, and the entertainment. Drinks, Wi-Fi, gratuities, and specialty dining are extra, either one at a time or bundled into a package. Princess offers Princess Premier, and Holland America offers Have It All.
On Oceania, gratuities, specialty dining, and Wi-Fi are included, and at booking you choose either a beer and wine package or an onboard credit. Explora Journeys includes nearly everything: drinks (including Champagne and premium spirits), Wi-Fi, gratuities, the spa's thermal area, and all but one of the restaurants.
That difference is the biggest thing people notice when they move up. You stop signing for everything, and that "nickel and dimed" feeling mostly goes away.
How the costs compare
At first glance, luxury fares look much higher. But that's not the whole story. To compare fairly, take the premium fare and add the extras you'd actually buy, like a drink package, specialty dining, Wi-Fi, and gratuities. Then compare that total to the luxury fare.
When Marc and I priced the same week on all five lines for our video, the gap between a premium line with all the extras added and a luxury line was smaller than most people expect. It isn't always close, and it changes with every sailing, but it's worth pricing both before you decide.
A few tips when you compare:
Look at the price per night, not just the total. Luxury itineraries often run longer, which can make the total look bigger than it really is.
Check what each package actually covers. Princess Premier is the closest a premium line gets to luxury-style inclusions. Holland America's Have It All is a good value but covers less, with just one specialty dinner on a week-long cruise and limits on drinks.
Compare similar itineraries and dates. Prices vary a lot by season, ship, and route.
Space and service
This is the part you feel the moment you step on board, and there are two numbers that explain it.
The first is the space ratio: a ship's size (its gross tonnage) divided by its guests. The higher the number, the more room each guest has. The second is crew per guest, which tells you how many people are there to take care of you.
Cruise line | Ship | Space ratio | Crew per guest |
Holland America | Pinnacle class | 37 | 1 crew member for every 2.6 guests |
Princess | Star Princess and Sun Princess | 41 | 1 for every 2.7 guests |
Celebrity | Celebrity Xcel | 43 | 1 for every 2.2 guests |
Oceania | Marina and Riviera | 53 | 1 for every 1.6 guests |
Oceania | Vista and Allura | 56 | 1 for every 1.5 guests |
Explora Journeys | Explora I and II | 69 | 1 for every 1.25 guests |
Every premium ship lands in the high 30s to low 40s for space, and every luxury ship is above 50. In real life, that means no hunting for a lounge chair, no lines at the buffet, and a much calmer pool deck.
The vibe on board
The big ships win on entertainment, hands down. If you love production shows, live music everywhere, and something going on all day, you'll notice the difference on a smaller ship. Luxury ships are quieter, especially in the evening. The dress code is smart casual, with no formal nights on Oceania or Explora.
Kids are a big factor for a lot of our viewers. Premium lines are family-friendly, which can mean a lot of children during school breaks. Oceania became adults-only in January 2026. Explora welcomes families and has a kids club, so if you want a more adult feel there, sail outside of school holidays.
Dining
Food is personal, so I'll just tell you what we noticed. On premium lines, there's good food, but the best of it is usually in the specialty restaurants that cost extra. On Oceania and Explora, specialty dining is included, and the quality is consistently high throughout the ship. You're also not dealing with crowds at mealtimes.
Itineraries and ports
Premium lines offer lots of short sailings and convenient home ports, sometimes ones you can drive to. Smaller luxury ships can get into smaller ports the big ships can't, and some itineraries include overnights and longer port days. The trade-off is fewer short sailings, so you may need to fly to meet the ship.
One question I always ask clients: is your trip about the ship, or about the places you're going? If it's the places, smaller ships often come out ahead.
The middle option: a ship within a ship
There's also a hybrid that a lot of people love: the ship within a ship. That's the Yacht Club on MSC, the Retreat on Celebrity, the Sanctuary Collection on Princess's Sun Princess and Star Princess, and the Haven on Norwegian. Suite guests get private lounges, restaurants, and sun decks, plus everything the big ship offers.
To be upfront, Marc and I haven't stayed in one yet, so I won't pretend to review it. But if you want more privacy and perks and still love the energy of a big ship, it's worth a look before you jump to a luxury line.
Who fits where
Stay with premium if:
You travel with kids or grandkids
You love shows, activities, and variety
You mostly take short getaways
You value the loyalty status you've built
Try a ship within a ship if:
You want more privacy and perks
You still love having the whole big ship to enjoy
Make the jump to luxury if:
Crowds wear you down
Food is a big part of your vacation
The ports matter most to you
You're booking a longer sailing
You're tired of everything being extra
Our take
It doesn't have to be all one or the other, either. You could take a big-ship cruise with the grandkids one year and a luxury sailing as a couple the next.
If you're on the fence, ask yourself one question: what matters most to you on vacation, variety or peace and quiet?
Want to see the real difference for your dates?
Every couple and every trip is different. I'm happy to price a premium line and a luxury line side by side for your dates, with all the extras added in, so you can see the real difference before you decide.
Website: twinpalmsworldtravel.com Email: judy@twinpalmsworldtravel.com Phone: 203-590-1641

Comments